Originally Answered: Could Obi have brought Anakin back to light on Mustafar? no Obi Wan will not bring Anakin to the dark side. You really think that thing that brought him to the dark side would help him.
Could ObiWan have spoken to Anakin?
Originally Answered: Why didn’t Obi Wan try to talk to Anakin while they were fighting? He has. He attempted to speak to her before the fight, during the fight, and at the end of the fight. Anakin pushed him away, refusing to budge.
What if ObiWan turns Anakin to the light?
If Anakin had been brought to light (which I don’t think would have happened even without the fight of Padmes), he would have become the greatest Jedi of all time. His knowledge and power above/in the Force would have been unmatched.
What would happen if ObiWan saved Anakin?
Originally Answered: What if ObiWan saved Anakin at the end of their duel, took him and his wife to Polis Massa and resuscitated them both? Most likely Yoda would have executed Anakin. Otherwise Anakin would have found his way back to Palpatine. Anakin was pretty far.
Why didn’t ObiWan try to ransom Anakin?
Because this duel against Mustafar convinced him that Anakin was beyond saving. He came to decide whether Anakin should be killed as Yoda had suggested.
Could ObiWan have turned Anakin?
no Obi Wan will not bring Anakin to the dark side.
Could ObiWan have beaten Anakin?
Anakin could have actually beat him if he had NOT been a student of ObiWans. They spent many thousands of hours in training and practice and knew each other’s movements as if they were their own. This is actually the real reason why ObiWan didn’t lose to Anakin quickly and was able to beat him in the end.
Did ObiWan let Anakin down?
ObiWan (and the Jedi in general) failed Anakin by imposing their dogmatic rules on him and disregarding him. They were afraid of Anakin’s potential. They let Palpatine get under Anakin’s skin. The Jedi were largely responsible for Anakin’s fall to the dark side.
Could ObiWan have saved Anakin?
By the time they found out about Darth Sidious’ plans, Anakin had already sworn allegiance to the Dark Lord of the Sith. Still, it’s clear that even in his final moments, ObiWan cared deeply for his former padawan. … So Obi Wan left him disembodied, not expecting Palpatine to come and rescue his fallen Padawa
Why didn’t ObiWan save Anakin from the lava?
During their confrontation on Mustafar, he was heartbroken when he saw what had happened to Anakin. Even when he had the chance to kill him outright, the Jedi Master couldn’t bring himself to kill him. Instead, ObiWan left him limbless, not expecting Palpatine to come and rescue his fallen Padawa.
What would happen if ObiWan refused to fight Anakin?
ObiWan would have suffered a similar fate during the Battle of Mustafar with no family connection to him, so any attempt to redeem him for lack of combat would have failed on ObiWan as Anakin would have killed him. Also, Anakin felt he had gone too far.
How did ObiWan react to Anakin’s takeover?
It’s pretty clear that ObiWan Kenobi and Yoda lost hope in Anakin, they saw no chance of salvation, as ObiWan told Luke in Return of the Jedi, “He’s more of a machine now than human.” ObiWan and Yoda saw no hope of redemption from Anakin, further evidenced by the two constantly urging Luke to stand up and kill.